The following is a modified post I recently made on Marketwatch.com.
It is hard to argue with a buy and hold investment strategy, until you look at the numbers.
It took the S&P 500 7 YEARS to get back to even from the high hit in March of 2000. Now it is down around 13% from its new all time high hit in October of 2007.
Sure, if you held emerging markets, real estate investment trusts and commodities during the last 8+ years your total portfolio would be up. But how many buy and hold investors include asset classes outside of US & International Equities and Bonds? Some yes, but not as many as you would think. I look at portfolios of the average investor all the time. While we are at it, how many 401k plans include those asset classes? Very few.
One questions for investment advisors and the media that adopt the B&H strategy with clients, if the results are so spectacular why don’t you publish ACTUAL performance numbers? I am sure I have missed some examples, but the performance numbers I come across most often from B&H advisors and the media are based on back tested mutual fund performance, not actual client accounts. There is a VERY BIG difference.
Oh yeah, and Paul Farrell’s Lazy portfolio numbers, they only go back about 5 years. So the portfolios started just about at the bottom of the 2000-2002 bear market. It has not been terribly difficult to generate double digit returns from just about any asset class (except bonds) in the last 5 years.
Buy and hold can be fine if you have the right expectations. If you are too aggressive, it is going to be very painful to watch the declines roll in year after year (yes, bear markets can last longer than one year), especially if you are in retirement and now pulling income from your investments.
My advice, if you are going to use a B&H strategy, use a balanced allocation (approximately 40% in bonds) hold several equity and bond asset classes, keep expenses low, and expect your average long term return to be about 8%.
For the record, I use a hybrid model. I construct highly diversified but unique and focused portfolios. I over and underweight asset classes based on expectations of the future and right now I am focused on protecting and profiting from rising inflation.